From the AP:
MONTGOMERY, Ala. (AP) — A man whose beating by five Birmingham police officers was caught on a dashboard video is suing the fired officers, the police chief and the city, saying he suffered severe and permanent injuries.
On Jan. 23, 2008, police chased the 38-year-old Warren, ramming his car to stop him and running it off the road. Warren was ejected and was apparently unconscious when officers began kicking him and beating him with a billy club and their fists.
Gayle Gear, who represents the officers, said they are upstanding servicemen and will file for qualified immunity from being sued. Gear said she doesn’t expect the case to go before a jury for years, if ever.
“It’s not unusual for a city to be sued and its officers to be sued,” she said. “There’s lots of lawsuits against various municipalities. We defend them and as a general rule, we prevail.”
For anybody living on Mars the past couple of days, the “Birmingham Beatdown:”
The problem Mr. Warren faces is police immunity and Ms. Gear is correct in many respects. These are very difficult lawsuits and very difficult to win. Mr. Warren being in prision doesn’t help either.
However, beating an unconscious man should trigger liability in this case. Ms. Gear’s comment about this taking years could rule the day, especially if that is the defense strategy.